By the co-author of the best-reviewed Disney World guidebook ever -- The easy Guide to Your First Walt Disney World Visit.

yourfirstvisit.net—Disney World Instructions for the First-Time Visitor





Walt Disney World’s Moderate Resorts



By Dave Shute

THE MODERATE RESORTS AT WALT DISNEY WORLD

Sassagoula-River-Cruise-at-Port-Orleans-RiversideYou can have a wonderful visit at any Walt Disney World resort. However, this site recommends that first time visitors to Walt Disney World avoid the moderate resorts, while noting that these resorts are wonderful for visits after the first. (See this for why.)

That said, the moderates do represent almost 30% of the room capacity of Walt Disney World, and will be sought by some you regardless of this site’s advice, or because this site’s recommended resorts are sold out. (For what the moderates provide, and how they compare to the other Disney World resort classes, click here)

Disney's The Cabins at Fort Wilderness - Floor Plan from yourfirstvisit.net

Because of this, I’ve stayed in each of the moderate resorts multiple times, including in each of their major room variants. Since I began working on this site, I’ve stayed in the moderates 25 times, for more than 80 nights.

DISNEY WORLD MODERATE RESORT RECOMMENDATIONS

Main-Pool-at-Disneys-Coronado-Springs-ResortIt’s easy to either under-rate or over-rate the moderates.

For the traditional moderates (the Cabins are a special case) you’ll typically pay about twice the price of the values, without them being clearly being twice as good, and half as much as for the deluxes, without them clearly providing half the value the deluxes do.

Compared to the values, the moderates provide much more and more livable space in their rooms; nicer landscaping (except the Cabins); queen rather than full beds in three of them (Riverside, French Quarter, and Coronado Springs; queens are also now in all standard Caribbean Beach rooms, but not in its Pirate rooms); coffee pots; table service restaurants in all but French Quarter, and less garish theming.

The moderates also provide the most cost-effective way to sleep five (in the Alligator Bayou section of Riverside, and in newly-refurbed five-person rooms at Caribbean Beach) and the most cost-effective way to get a full kitchen (in The Cabins at Disney’s Fort Wilderness Resort).

On the other hand, they have both less overall kid appeal and less convenience than two of the values–Art of Animation and Pop Century–so if you don’t need queen beds or one of the other distinctive features of the moderates, one of those two will be a better choice for many first time family visitors.

Compared to the deluxes, the moderates are less fun, have much less good dining, are less convenient to at least one theme park, and have many fewer services and amenities.  Bedroom sizes are more comparable to those in the deluxes than you’d think, especially the half of deluxes with smaller rooms. See this for more on square footage and livability.

You’ll find many sites and books that act as though all the moderates have the same rooms (although they do get the differences at the Cabins).  This has never really been true. Floor plan and room type distinctions are available in the individual reviews.

DISTINCTIONS AMONG THE DISNEY WORLD MODERATE RESORTS

Resorts are ranked on this site for first time visitors based first on their kid appeal, and then on their convenience.

On this basis, the moderates are recommended in the following order:

  1. Caribbean Beach: most kid appeal, least convenient, mostly queens but still full beds in the Pirate rooms in Trinidad South; 5 person rooms built and bookable except in the Pirate rooms
  2. Coronado Springs: best overall value for money, most amenities, some kid appeal, queen beds
  3. Port Orleans Riverside: most popular
  4. Port Orleans French Quarter: most popular with adults, most convenient; no table-service restaurant; queen beds
  5. The Cabins at Fort Wilderness: only one that sleeps six, only one with full kitchen, much more expensive than first four, least convenient; full or smaller beds

(The first four are very close–especially 3 and 4…)

A-Beach-at-Disneys-Caribbean-Beach-Resort-2Caribbean Beach

Only moderate with no elevators at all. Only moderate with no indoor bar/lounge. Only traditional moderate with some full beds, although full beds have been replaced with queens in all rooms except the Pirate Rooms in Trinidad South (the larger beds in the Cabins are also full beds.). Best pool of any moderate. Most kid-appealing of moderates. Many renovated  rooms now sleep five–the fifth on a fold-down murphy bed.

Map-of-Disneys-Coronado-Springs-Resort1Coronado Springs

Only moderate with a spa. Only moderate with a health club. Only moderate with substantial room service. Only moderate with only one sink per room, rather than two. Only moderate that hosts conventions. Sometimes a few dollars more per night than other moderates.

Disney's Port Orleans Riverside Alligator Bayou Standard 5 Person Room Floor Plan from yourfirstvisit.net (1280x919)Port Orleans Riverside

One of only two moderates that can be booked for 5 (only in Alligator Bayou section, with fifth on a 66″ Murphy Bed). No elevators in Alligator Bayou section. (Magnolia Bend section has elevators.) With Port Orleans French Quarter, only moderate not on a lake.

Serpent-Slide-Disneys-Port-Orleans-French-QuarterPort Orleans French Quarter

Only moderate with no sit-down restaurant. With Port Orleans Riverside, only moderate with no lake. Only moderate with no quiet pool. Most compact of moderates. Most romantic of moderates.

Kitchen The Cabins at Fort Wilderness from yourfirstvisit.netThe Cabins at Fort Wilderness

Only moderate that can sleep six. Only moderate with a full kitchen. Only moderate with 2 rooms. Only moderate that takes two transport acts to get to a theme park. Only moderate with a porch, and a barbecue grill. Only moderate materially more expensive than the others.

*Three, four, or five moderates? Unnecessary confusion has been caused in the past by websites, guidebooks—and Wikipedia—as to whether there are three or four or five moderates. Many group the two Port Orleans resorts as one, leave out the Cabins at Fort Wilderness, and hence have counted 3 moderate resorts.

However, the two Port Orleans resorts are listed separately in Disney’s list of resorts by type that comes at the bottom of every resort’s home page, and have separate listings in Disney’s online “I know the Resort I want” list; neither list provides an entry for “Port Orleans Resort.” Moreover, they have entirely separate check-in processes, and have reasonable physical distance between them.

For these reasons, the two are treated as distinct resorts in this discussion.

In 2009, Disney complicated this issue by adding the Cabins at Disney’s Fort Wilderness Resort to the group of resorts it labels as “moderates.” Disney’s intent in doing so was to make clearer the level of amenities one gets in one of these Cabins—higher than that at a value, not as nice as in a deluxe, comparable to the other four moderates.

So five moderates…

MORE ON WHERE TO STAY AT DISNEY WORLD

Follow yourfirstvisit.net on Facebook or Google+ or Twitter or Pinterest!!

RELATED STUFF

12 comments

1 Nicolò { 02.04.15 at 4:28 pm }

Hello,
first of all, the site is really great and I’ve used it for my previous trips! I’m planning my next trip to Disneyworld. I’ve been there already two times, but next time my mother will be there with me for her first time and I really want it to be special for her. I really want to try for the first time a moderate resort (always been at the values) but I’m quite worried about the big dimensions of these resort…I’m interested in Coronado and Port Orleans Riverside but both are really huge! I saw that there are some bus stops around the resort and I was wondering if these are stop for bus that go just to the main building or if these are bus stops for all the parks.
do you suggest to take a preferred room? And, if I reserve a preferred room, can I choose the building where I want my room in the resort?
Thank you very much!
Ps sorry for my bad english

2 Dave { 02.05.15 at 9:09 am }

Nicolo, I’m so glad the site has helped!!

The bus stops are designed to get you to the parks, not the front, but typically at least one of the bus routes will go from your stop to the front. Ask when you check in which bus it is.

You can request a specific building among the preferred options. It will not be guaranteed, though. See this for how to do so: http://yourfirstvisit.net/2014/03/25/getting-your-disney-world-room-request/

Among the moderates, French Quarter is by far the most compact and easy to get around. See this: http://yourfirstvisit.net/2013/02/12/review-disneys-port-orleans-french-quarter-resort-2/ If you do another resort, I would definitely pay for a preferred room!

3 Nicolò { 02.15.15 at 10:34 am }

Thank you very much Dave!

just another question…
I saw the room request section and I remember that last time I went in disneyworld, I made a reservation for a standard room, not a preferred one, and I had the possibility to made a request like the one showed in the room request page you showed me.
So, I’m quite confused…any guest (standard or preferred room) can made a specific room request? But who made a reservation for a preferred room has a major possibility to have his request accomplished?
Sorry for my bad english, I hope the question was clear..
Thank you very much again! :)

4 Dave { 02.16.15 at 8:03 am }

Nicolo, the preferred rooms are in six buildings–all three buildings at Trinidad North, and the three buildings closest to the central services in Martinique. Anyone can make a request; those who paid preferred will go into one of these six buildings.

5 Harry { 03.29.15 at 6:02 pm }

I’ve stayed at all the values, the art of animation seemed to be the nicest ,I have 4 kids and a wife we want to stay at a moderate but I don’t know which to pick , I will get two rooms next to each other like I did at pop , I don’t want to walk , I want to be next to the main pool and buses , I definetly don’t want to walk up steps any suggestions

6 Dave { 03.30.15 at 7:30 am }

Harry, your best choice, by far, is Port Orleans French Quarter.

7 Wendy { 05.21.15 at 6:42 pm }

OK – some new rooms have opened up for free dining during our time…

Pop for 2300 and some change OR Caribbean for 2700 and some change? The second gets us the higher dining plan…

Ideas?

Thanks,

Wendy

8 Wendy { 05.22.15 at 11:25 pm }

I changed to Coronado Springs – the CBR was no longer available…

Who knows how many times I will change!

Thanks,

Wendy

9 Dave { 05.24.15 at 10:59 am }

K, Wend,y as you’ve noted I’ve gotten a bit behind (am also behind on that other matter) but I think you will love Coronado Springs with its bigger rooms (bigger even than WL in the bedroom area) and queen beds, and find value in the upgrade to the DP!!

10 Wendy { 05.24.15 at 1:03 pm }

I think it looks good, too…and I got Be our Guest! If CBR comes up again, should I think of switching or should I just stay at CSR?

We are trying to decide which other sit-down meals – we want three more in Epcot, we think. The two in Japan look good, as does the one in France (not M Paul as that takes two “coupons”), and we love Living with the Land – so maybe the Garden Grill? Any thoughts? Any we are missing? WE are also thinking about Chef Mickey on the lats morning before we drive to Sandestin.

Thanks! June is in sight!

Wendy

11 Dave { 05.26.15 at 8:06 am }

Wendy, CSR is better for adults, CBR for kids. But either can have fun in either, so I would not obsess over the differences. For Epcot what you are thinking is mostly fine. In the book we specifically recommend Biergarten in Germany, Via Napoli in Italy, Akershus Banquet Hall in Norway, and San Angel Inn in Mexico.

12 Wendy { 05.26.15 at 7:24 pm }

Thanks!

Leave a Comment | Ask a Question | Note a Problem easy 15 banner

My response to questions and comments will be on the same page as the original comment, likely within 24-36 hours . . . I reserve the right to edit and delete comments as I choose . . . All rights reserved. Copyright 2008-2015 . . . Unless otherwise noted, all photos are by me--even the ones in focus--except for half a dozen from my niecelets . . . This site is entirely unofficial and not authorized by any organizations written about in it . . . All references to Disney and other copyrighted characters, trademarks, marks, etc., are made solely for editorial purposes. The author makes no commercial claim to their use . . . Nobody's perfect, so follow any advice here at your own risk.